January 17, 2005
The Ist
Meet Mr. Ist. Or as his awed colleagues call him The Ist. Now, Ist is a very religious guy. So religious, he is full of spirit. Which comes in handy, since lately he has to take much shit from his godless-heathen colleagues.
For some reasons, his colleagues have much disdain towards his blind faith. Their rationale being that blind faith has caused considerable havoc in this world. And that only the path of logic and rationality is safe.
Our Ist is resourceful. He promptly points out the flimsiness of deductive logic. His colleagues are pushed back for a while, but even he can discern that these are not potent enough arguments. He knows his colleagues shall come back like Christ after His Resurrection. Which is a bad analogy of course, for his heathen colleagues are sadly, unlike Christ, going to Hell.
And come back his colleagues do, with potent counter-arguments.
Ist's cheek twitches with righteous indignation. But our Ist is, at heart, a compassionate guy. He looks upto the sky. When they burn in hot oil in Hell, Father, let it not be mustard oil, for it smells; he prays.
As he's looking upto the sky, he's suddenly filled with divine inspiration flowing up his spine. A second later he realizes it's actually a cramp from sinfully craning his neck with such gay abandon.
As he massages his neck, he gets another inspiration - this time thankfully its just an epiphany. About what shall be his next salvo to his heathen colleagues. Ist is so happy, he almost cranes his neck to the sky again.
The next day, he points out to his heathen colleagues a study that religious people are more happy.
He looks at them smugly - let's see them tackle that, he seems to be thinking. But then the heathens promptly quote a certain George Bernard Shaw, no doubt another poor going-to-hell chap, that slobbering drunks are happier too.
It is when he is shaking his head - both at the quote and due to his neck cramps actually - that he realizes one major plus factor for blind faith that can never be out-salvoed.
Not its Happiness Inducing. Not its Gates of Heaven Opening.
But simply yet powerfully - its great capability for inspiring.
Motivation, he argues, is a fairly important component of what drives a human. And one of the biggest motivators is spiritual inspiration after all.
One has to just listen to singers like the late great MS Subbalakshmi; her songs, her bhajans. Can one deny the palpable inspiration, the strength that she draws from her religion? Look, he tells his colleagues, look at how the much-reviled "blind faith" towards religion can push people to the creative heights of MS Subbalakshmi and A.R. Rahman and countless other painters and writers and singers.
How can you have disdain towards that which drives mankind's greatest achievements, he asks.
Is it not something to be nurtured, rather than reviled?
Actually, The Ist feels a pang of sympathy for his colleagues. He shakes his head. All this beautiful sky above them, its twinkling stars, but nary an inspiration to draw from it - who'd want to live a life like that, he wonders.
For some reasons, his colleagues have much disdain towards his blind faith. Their rationale being that blind faith has caused considerable havoc in this world. And that only the path of logic and rationality is safe.
Our Ist is resourceful. He promptly points out the flimsiness of deductive logic. His colleagues are pushed back for a while, but even he can discern that these are not potent enough arguments. He knows his colleagues shall come back like Christ after His Resurrection. Which is a bad analogy of course, for his heathen colleagues are sadly, unlike Christ, going to Hell.
And come back his colleagues do, with potent counter-arguments.
Ist's cheek twitches with righteous indignation. But our Ist is, at heart, a compassionate guy. He looks upto the sky. When they burn in hot oil in Hell, Father, let it not be mustard oil, for it smells; he prays.
As he's looking upto the sky, he's suddenly filled with divine inspiration flowing up his spine. A second later he realizes it's actually a cramp from sinfully craning his neck with such gay abandon.
As he massages his neck, he gets another inspiration - this time thankfully its just an epiphany. About what shall be his next salvo to his heathen colleagues. Ist is so happy, he almost cranes his neck to the sky again.
The next day, he points out to his heathen colleagues a study that religious people are more happy.
He looks at them smugly - let's see them tackle that, he seems to be thinking. But then the heathens promptly quote a certain George Bernard Shaw, no doubt another poor going-to-hell chap, that slobbering drunks are happier too.
It is when he is shaking his head - both at the quote and due to his neck cramps actually - that he realizes one major plus factor for blind faith that can never be out-salvoed.
Not its Happiness Inducing. Not its Gates of Heaven Opening.
But simply yet powerfully - its great capability for inspiring.
Motivation, he argues, is a fairly important component of what drives a human. And one of the biggest motivators is spiritual inspiration after all.
One has to just listen to singers like the late great MS Subbalakshmi; her songs, her bhajans. Can one deny the palpable inspiration, the strength that she draws from her religion? Look, he tells his colleagues, look at how the much-reviled "blind faith" towards religion can push people to the creative heights of MS Subbalakshmi and A.R. Rahman and countless other painters and writers and singers.
How can you have disdain towards that which drives mankind's greatest achievements, he asks.
Is it not something to be nurtured, rather than reviled?
Actually, The Ist feels a pang of sympathy for his colleagues. He shakes his head. All this beautiful sky above them, its twinkling stars, but nary an inspiration to draw from it - who'd want to live a life like that, he wonders.
COMMENTS:
<< Home
Yes, M.S. Subbulakshmi may have been inspired by religion, but she was also inspired by her husband's "commandments". And believed that all young women today should be the same... that the reason there are so many divorces and that Indian society is generally going to hell is all because young women today are not afraid to stand up for themselves and "talk back", and basically refuse to be vines clinging to their parents and their husbands. (Did you miss The Hindu full-page article on her?)
Does Mr. Ist agree with that? If so, he is not the compassionate guy you try to paint him.
If he doesn't, and he's still bothered about convincing folks, maybe time for him to come up with another argument.
Me, I am not as compassionate, and think they deserve to burn in hell anyway (or be condemned to rebirth), so I do not bother convincing people. I like finding contradictions, though :)
Does Mr. Ist agree with that? If so, he is not the compassionate guy you try to paint him.
If he doesn't, and he's still bothered about convincing folks, maybe time for him to come up with another argument.
Me, I am not as compassionate, and think they deserve to burn in hell anyway (or be condemned to rebirth), so I do not bother convincing people. I like finding contradictions, though :)
Shobha - spot on. You grasped the main point of the post. You're right that just because MSS was inspired by a overly dominating husband does not imply that overly dominating husbands are a good thing.
One can only say that inspiration is a good thing. Nothing more.
The post is from the POV of a theist just to play devil's advocate. Not only am I not Mr. Ist, I'm also gonna burn in Hell.
One can only say that inspiration is a good thing. Nothing more.
The post is from the POV of a theist just to play devil's advocate. Not only am I not Mr. Ist, I'm also gonna burn in Hell.
The post is from the POV of a theist just to play devil's advocate.Oooh. I think the devil's advocate needs to come up with more interesting arguments though. :)
Which is hard, since most people (given the general mindset today of "live and let live!" -- or, "go burn in hell, heehee!") tend to believe faith is a personal thing.
Post a Comment
Which is hard, since most people (given the general mindset today of "live and let live!" -- or, "go burn in hell, heehee!") tend to believe faith is a personal thing.
<< Home
